What is mass extinction and are we facing a sixth one?

What is a mass extinction?

Extinction is a part of life – animals and plants disappear all the time. About 98% of all the organisms that have ever existed on our planet are now extinct.

When a species goes extinct, its role in the ecosystem is usually filled by new species, or other existing ones. Earth’s ‘normal’ extinction rate is often thought to be somewhere between 0.1 and 1 species per 10,000 species per 100 years. This is known as the background rate of extinction.

A mass extinction event is when species vanish much faster than they’re replaced. This is usually defined as about 75% of the world’s species being lost in a short period of geological time – less than 2.8 million years.

Dr Katie Collins, our Senior Curator of Benthic Molluscs, says, “it’s difficult to identify when a mass extinction may have started and ended. However, there are five big events that we know of, where extinction was much higher than normal background rate, and these are often used to decide whether we are going through a sixth one now.”

How many mass extinctions have there been?

In the last 500 million years, five great mass extinction events have changed the face of life on Earth. We know what caused some of them, but others are still a mystery.

1. The Ordovician-Silurian mass extinction occurred 443 million years ago and wiped out approximately 85% of all species. Scientists think it was caused by temperatures plummeting and huge glaciers forming, which caused sea levels to drop dramatically. This was followed by a period of rapid warming. Many small marine species died out.
2. The Devonian mass extinction event took place 374 million years ago and killed about three-quarters of the world’s species, most of which were marine invertebrates that lived at the bottom of the sea. This was a period of many environmental changes, including global warming and cooling, a rise and fall of sea levels and a reduction in oxygen and carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. We don’t know exactly what triggered the extinction event.
3. The Permian mass extinction, which happened 250 million years ago, has been Earth’s largest and most devastating extinction event. The Permian-Triassic extinction is also known as the Great Dying. More than 95% of all species were eradicated, including most of the vertebrates that had begun to evolve by this time. Some scientists think Earth was hit by a large asteroid that filled the air with dust particles, blocking out the Sun and causing acid rain. Others think there was a large volcanic explosion that increased carbon dioxide and made the oceans toxic.
4. The Triassic mass extinction event occurred 200 million years ago, eliminating about 80% of Earth’s species, including many types of dinosaurs. This was probably caused by colossal geological activity that increased carbon dioxide levels and global temperatures, as well as ocean acidification.
5. The Cretaceous mass extinction event occurred 66 million years ago, killing 78% of all species, including the remaining non-avian dinosaurs. This was most likely caused by an asteroid hitting the Earth in what is now Mexico, potentially compounded by ongoing flood volcanism in what is now India.

What causes mass extinctions?

Past mass extinctions were caused by extreme temperature changes, rising or falling sea levels and catastrophic, one-off events such as huge volcanic eruptions or an asteroid hitting Earth.

We know about them because we can see how life has changed in the fossil record. For instance, a large part of Katie’s work includes exploring extinction through fossils such as bivalves.

Katie says, “bivalves have been around for 500 million years, making them one of the oldest groups of fossils we can study and still see how they live and survive today. We get some really good continuous data from them all around the world.”

While fossils can tell us a lot about how life used to be on Earth, there are still many questions that remain unanswered.

“The Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction is the youngest mass extinction event, and probably the most studied,” Katie adds. “We should understand the Cretaceous event pretty well, but many aspects of it, including the lead-in, the cause and the recovery, are all still areas of active research.”

Are we in a sixth mass extinction?

We’re experiencing drastic changes to our planet, including extreme weather such as flooding, drought and wildfires.

Research, including some led by our scientists, shows humans are the cause of these changes. Since the Industrial Revolution, we’ve been putting pressure on nature by using its resources without supporting recovery.

For example, land use change is continuing to destroy swathes of natural landscapes. Humans have already transformed over 70% of land surfaces and are using about three-quarters of freshwater resources.

Agriculture is also a leading cause of soil degradation, deforestation, pollution and biodiversity loss. It’s diminishing wild spaces and driving out countless species from their natural habitats, forcing them to clash with humans for resources or leaving them vulnerable.

Katie says, “many large animals are culled because they’re seen as a risk to humans. People will hunt predatory birds disproportionally as they consider them a threat to farming, although they mostly eat rabbits.”

“A lot of wolves have been removed in North America because they’re seen as predators of livestock and that’s caused a trophic ecological cascade.”

Invasive species, many of which are introduced by humans, are also threatening ecosystems all over the world. Introduced species compete with local species for resources and often diminish the quality of biodiversity in the area, sometimes causing extinction. These are just some of the devastating changes caused by humans.

All life on Earth is finely interwoven. This delicate balance has been established over millions of years. As one species becomes extinct, many other species are affected, putting a number of ecosystems in danger of collapsing.

Naturally, extinction occurs over hundreds and thousands of years, which allows nature to slowly replace what has been lost. But humans have sped up this process to a dangerous rate.

Katie says, “the current rate of extinction is between 100 and 1,000 times higher than the pre-human background rate of extinction, which is jaw-dropping. We’re definitely going through a sixth mass extinction.”

Never before has a single species been responsible for such destruction on Earth.

Could we stop a sixth mass extinction?

Mass extinctions are a large and complex issue. They can be slow burners, taking millions of years to unfold.

Right now, it seems likely we’re experiencing a sixth, and it’s undoubtably the result of human actions, including human-induced climate change.

“The floods and wildfires we’re hearing about in the news now will become regular occurrences in 50 years’ time,' says Katie. 'They’ll test the resilience of our buildings, infrastructures, transatlantic cables, satellites and more.”

“These natural disasters are going to exacerbate existing inequalities, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Research shows that if we change how we use natural resources now, the future could be a positive one for the next generation.”

“If we can work on reducing the negative impact we’ve had on the climate, then other things will also improve, such as the number of species that are currently threatened by habitat loss.”

“We need to work on how we access and use natural resources, including land management. Habitat loss is a huge problem and land use is tied in with that.”

Many believe the changes we need to see now can be achieved fastest by prioritising the protection and preservation of nature over the interests of financial systems.

Katie says, “I know there’s a lot of emphasis on individual action but most of the climate-altering pollution and fossil fuel burning is the responsibility of a small number of parties.”

“It’d be much more effective for individuals to put pressure on policymakers and businesses to reduce emissions and target companies that are major emitters.”

The future of our world hangs on our making what is perhaps the biggest international effort in history to reduce human impacts. We all have an active role to play, which requires deep transformation of our values, attitudes and behaviours.